Athens Pizza

Reviews

• Jena Marie D.

  star star star star star 20 September 2026

  Delicious pizza, low prices and super friendly. My husband and I used to meet here for lunch when I worked in Westborough and he worked in Marlborough - it was a great place for us to sit and have a cheap lunch. Their small 10" pizzas are only around $5 for a single topping, so if you add a soda to that, you're well under $10 for a fantastic lunch.
  We just ordered some pizzas from them for an evening rehearsal with a few select chorus kids and they were proclaimed to be delicious by the hungry middle schoolers - we all know the affinity of teenagers to cheap pizza! They also very generously delivered us a bonus box of warm brownies along with the pizzas, a totally unexpected treat to follow up a tasty dinner. The BBQ chicken pizza is one of their most popular and the student who ordered that particular pizza said it was really good. Another ordered bacon on his, which came in big strips, not crumbled salad topping bits like some places use. Personally, I prefer the spinach and feta pizza so much that I haven't ordered the other ones there, though I've tried them.
  They also do subs and the usual pizza place fare. They don't have a website and I don't have a menu handy, but perhaps someone else on Yelp can add to this! :)

• R P.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 14 September 2026

  Ordered the pizza special from their menu and got a small $11.23 Pizza...   Pepperoni, two kinds of sausage, white mushrooms, onion and green peppers (none saute).  Very tasty... No napkins...
  
  But not quite what was advertised and expected:
  Pizza Special (Pickup Only)
  4.25
  Pickup only.
  
  Two stars off for the bait and switch...

• Mike R.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 9 September 2026

  The delivery guy tells me every time(4 times now) to not use grub hub and to call for delivery... maybe you shouldn't make grub hub an option ya silly billy.
  
  Oh and food is eh
  Pizza-eh
  Jalapeño poppers-eh
  Cheesy bacon fries-yuck

• Shane S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 5 September 2026

  I ordered from Athens Pizza one time on a lunch break and it was the most disappointing pizza experience ever. I called an order and was quoted 15 minutes, showed up more than 20 minutes later and my food wasn't ready, ok sure. I had only ordered a small cheese steak and a small cheese pizza to split with a friend should be another minute or two right?. Sitting in there waiting I noticed how dirty the place was. Cob webs, water damaged/moldy framed art, probably years of hand prints on the drink cooler doors... then I eventually get the food which took about 35+ minutes from original order while they were clearly not busy. Only one person came in and one delivery left while I was there and no one working seemed to be in any sort of rush at all. Then the food........ the small cheese steak was D R E N C H E D in mayo. Like inedibly drenched. I didn't even order mayo.. then the pizza had the most bland flavor I ever experienced.. like I'm saying this pizza made a Cumberland Farms gas station pizza look like a gourmet pie from North End. To top off the experience, 0 apologies for the more than doubled wait, and they were a little rude. You can have off days, but this didn't feel like it. Seemed like an off decade maybe. You can see my yelp reviews, I very seldom leave negative feedback unless it's truly earned. The only thing this place gave me was a bad taste metaphorically and literally.

• Amber A.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 3 September 2026

  So far we are an hour and a half waiting on a small
  Pizza and salad that was supposed to take 30-40 mins.  Everything wrong.  First I had to repeat all my information to not one but two confused guys to order the food.  Then a confused guy called to say he was in the lobby (ordered to a hotel) but when I can down he wasn't there.  Called him and found out he had gone "to the other place".  The restaurant called me and said "ma'am don't give me a hard time, I apologize".  They offered a free drink.  I said the pizza should be free and he said no, so I told him I wouldn't pay for it and he could eat it.  Got a call six minutes ago from the delivery guy that he would be here in three minutes...
  
  Ah!  he arrived and yelled at me in front of the whole hotel.  Grinning and saying he wanted me to be happy in a tone that made one of the ladies comment after he walked out that she wouldn't have blamed me if I'd slapped him.  Classy joint.  The food is mediocre, so...